Tayari's Blog: More Links on Monday

Posted by TayariJones on October 1, 2007 04:53 PM
Filed under Travels & Rambles

  • Man-skin and pastels. Fred Smith got to design his own book cover!
  • I'm sending you to Pajamaland again. Carleen is talking to Kim Reid about the Atlanta Child Murders.
  • This is complicated. Carolyn See wrote a really unfavorable review of Porochista Khakpour's new novel, "Sons and Other Flammable Objects," in the Washington Post; weirdly enough, she formatted it as an open letter to the author. Here's a little sample:
    Two other things, and I'm pretty sure they'll be good enough reason for you to wave this review around to your friends as proof positive that your novel is as pearls before swine: How could anyone be so pedestrian as to question how often you use the word "snapped" instead of "said?" I didn't start counting until after Page 246, when I just couldn't take it anymore, but 17 times that verb pops up -- remember that's after Page 246 -- and three times on one page. It's not just Darius; they all snap like turtles, seemingly incapable of a pleasant sentence.

    Okay, got that? On to the next link.
  • Porochista Khakpour got really angry and let loose on her blog. Among the highlights:
    I am a bit confused at See being assigned to me. . .See lets the world see she is clearly a very bitter, confused old lady ("old" only being brought up because of her own fixation on my age.) I had never heard of See until I checked out her web site, which says it all: sometimes the good ol' cat ladies are the catttiest old ladies. . .and if that sounds nasty, well, See, respected as she may be as a reviewer and writer, uses her podium to express extreme dismay with someone of my age, gender, and ethnicity writing a book like mine (or any book maybe!), and that to me seems a bit of a violation of good review etiquette, at the very least.

  • And you know Galleycat was all over it.

  • [divider]

    There are 3 comments on "More Links on Monday". If you'd like to leave a comment, click here to jump down to the comments entry form.

    Comment #1, by carleen [TypeKey Profile Page]

    Thanks for the links! Kim's book is really good, so I hope this brings her some sales.

    October 1, 2007 08:12 PM

    Comment #2, by Jackie [TypeKey Profile Page]

    What is your take on this dispute, Tayari? Should the author have engaged in verbal battle with the reviewer? I happen to like Carolyn See and don't believe her to be a bitter old woman. Now I haven't read the book, but if it really has "snapped" all those times in it, I consider myself forwarned that it might be an irritating read. Do you think the author overreacted and can't take criticism in a professional way? Just curious about your opinion on this.

    October 1, 2007 10:19 PM

    Comment #3, by Michael Fischer [TypeKey Profile Page]

    Wow, what a petty review. A review written as an angry letter? WTF? I'm a bit disappointed that the WPo Book World would run that; I've always liked their book coverage and considered it professional.

    October 1, 2007 10:20 PM

    Your Comments

    You are signed in as (sign out)

    Please keep comments relevant to the topic. Inappropriate and offensive comments may be edited and/or removed without warning. Comments found on this site don't necessarily reflect the views of Tayari Jones.

    (optional)

    (required)